Have you noticed the number of calorie-counting sites on the internet? Yeah, me too. There are at least a trillion. Unfortunately, with great power comes great responsibility. (That co-opted quote has nothing to do with anything but I have heard it at least 5 times in the past two days so why not throw it in?) Calorie counting, by nature, exacts change with control and hyper-consciousness, and, well, those things have a lot to do with disordered eating, so is it healthy?
I went to the internet to find out. Instead of finding voices that sounded like mine, there were a lot of diet pages that weren't so healthy themselves. I didn't understand how no one was discussing this, as dieting is such a huge issue. Sometimes you ask and the internet answers, though, and a week later, I saw this post on Jezebel about my very question: Is calorie counting worth the effort and anxiety? The answer seems to be no. And I do think that for people who are relatively in touch with their eating habits, it's a routine that can quickly and unnecessarily spiral out of control. (Here is another interesting article that came shortly after the first, providing some follow-up inspiration.)
As I mentioned in an earlier post, I've spent the past nine months slowly altering my exercise and eating habits. As I've been overweight, um, my entire life, I know what it takes to diet. I went to a nutritionist at 7 and Weight Watchers at 10, and felt that the only way to be rewarded with many members of my family was through weight loss. Even today, talking to my grandma or other family members about weight comes down to these inescapable value judgments. What's funny is that, despite my grandma understanding this, she still brought up in conversation the other day how this one just lost weight and that one is down a few sizes again. All the women in my family are infamous for yo-yo dieting, so why is choosing a healthy lifestyle inferior to dropping 20 pounds in a month? (Hint: results! The latter is much more glamorous.)
I started by documenting my exercise progress only, hoping that exercise would be enough to lose weight at first. But no matter how good it felt to make myself active again, my small wins felt overshadowed. I went home and my weight loss went basically unnoticed, or it was eclipsed by my brother who managed to drop 30 pounds in what seemed like minutes (to my, yes, 9 months). My small progress didn't matter anymore, and my exercise routine fluctuated with my self-doubt. It was a few weeks ago when I finally realized that I'd have to start monitoring my calorie intake if I wanted faster results. I was hesitant; when I went through boxes at my grandma's, I found old notebooks I kept during high school diets with meticulously-documented calories, drawings of the body I had versus the body I wanted, pages of self-criticism. So to modify the original question: is it possible to have a history of weight issues and still count calories without being crazy?
For myself, the measure is temporarily required, so I decided to add a safeguard: my friend, Joanna. I often lament not having someone who has similar weight issues in the same city as me. It would be nice to have a motivator but also a person who can entirely relate to that struggle. (Worrying about my ass jiggling too much as we run through the park is a legitimate struggle and one that I worry Anne doesn't always understand--not to mention, my fat ass slows her down.) While Joanna and I got ourselves into some bad habits as teens, testing out diet pills and crash diets and cutting calories to unhealthy lows, I feel that we can do the opposite now. I made her take a vow of no crazy: there will be no criticism unless it is asked for, and only encouragement for accomplishments (no competitions). In writing down our calories, we can check each other, which means no one can eat too little and having another pair of eyes on me means I won't (always) eat too much. Joanna required a little more motivation, and since we're both a little obsessive (I monitor my monthly budget to the dollar), I decided to write down some ground rules, just in case I feel like following them. (They're a little fat-girl [slash me] specific...sorry about that?) So in case someone was searching the internet, trying to find a healthy-not-crazy way to think about counting calories when trying to lose a bit (a lot) of weight, here are some things to remember and, hopefully, truly believe:
1. I am writing things down in order to make better choices. The things that I eat are not a reflection of me except that they are changeable, and I hope to be as well.
2. Every day should not be a struggle but an opportunity to choose a healthy lifestyle.
3. I will not let writing things down devalue food and the enjoyment it offers. I will not restrict myself the things I enjoy, but, rather, learn to be satisfied with smaller portions.
4. Every day is a new day, every meal a new meal. I will view them separately and they will not impact each other negatively. I will study progress over time and work on my problem areas.
5. If I feel myself becoming unhappy and berating myself over food, I will rethink the reasons why I am disappointed in myself and remind myself of all the ways I am a successful woman.
6. Writing down what I eat is only a way to help myself learn and get used to a different lifestyle. The ultimate goal is not to lose weight but to become a healthier person who views food in a positive way.
7. There are reasons why I use food for emotional fulfillment, and as I make progress, I will need to explore my relationship with food and addictive tendencies. As I restrict food, I cannot allow obsession over restriction. I can also not allow a transferring of behavior to another addiction.
Last note: turns out, it's really hard (and embarrassing) to monitor this shit when you're drinking a lot. So...restricted drinking, that might be on the list. Might. Let's think about it.
Filling In For The Internet
Monday, November 10, 2008
Posted by
Linda
at
9:17 PM
|
Labels:
"Kiss My Fat Ass",
Listless,
Really Important Advice
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Find It
Linda's Weekly Entertainment
Reading: Cat's Cradle--Kurt Vonnegut
Watching: Weeds
Listening to: They Might Be Giants--First Kiss
Ashamed to enjoy: Wendy's Original Frosty
ARCHIVES
-
►
2009
(72)
-
►
June
(13)
- Smith Street Fair
- Bunnies, Clouds, And Thoughts
- Why Do We Hate Kate Gosselin?
- All-Over-The-Place Rambling About Smart Girls
- How-Not-To Video
- Don't Rain On My [Mermaid] Parade
- A Year of Fail
- We've Wasted A Year Of Your Life: Let's Celebrate!...
- The New York Aquarium
- "Aww...He Loves Her" --5:13
- The Hangover Reviewed (Somewhat Angrily)
- Up "Reviewed"
- Album of the Week: Chrisette Michele, Epiphany
-
►
May
(18)
- The First Abortion Provider Killed In A Decade
- I Hope You Find This As Interesting As I Do...
- Any Means Necessary
- Whoops, Wrong Desert
- Really Unimportant Star Trek "Review"
- Is "Withdrawal" Safe For Work?
- Precious: I'm Already Crying
- Casey Wilson And A '90s Rap Bonus Clip
- Let's Fight About It: Supreme Court Nominations
- Red States, Blue States, and the Rainbows In Betwe...
- The Loyal Rudderless Opposition
- Jesus Likes To Be The Only One In A Crown
- Bar Review: Washington Commons
- Redress Of Grievances
- Grimaldi's: Is There Ever NOT A Line?
- Better Than Fish Sticks
- Poetry Month: Response Post
- April Is Was National Poetry Month
-
►
April
(21)
- Swine Flu, Racism, Police Brutality: The Usual
- Eek, That's My Mayor
- A Good Way To Start Off May
- Song of the Week: Maxwell, "Pretty Wings"
- Death and Atheism: The University of Linda
- The Next British Invasion
- Mike Tyson Makes Sense (?)
- Adventureland Reviewed
- Throwback of the Week: Mary J. Blige, My Life
- There Are No Scooters In Brooklyn
- More "Vacation" Fun
- I AM SHAKING AND CRYING (Part II)
-
►
June
(13)
-
▼
2008
(157)
-
▼
November
(18)
- Why Am I So Awkward?
- But, Like, Isn't Segregation Not The Answer...Ever...
- Beyonce, Trivia, and an Unkindness of Ravens
- When It Goes Too Far
- Brighter Reflections To Come...Eventually
- 10 Worthwhile Minutes Out of 90
- The Worst Medium For Arguments
- What's Wrong With Hate?
- Proposition 8 Hate
- Filling In For The Internet
- Madagascar 2 Reviewed
- A New Day In America
- You're On Warning: The Office
- Gratuitous Pictures of Rahm Emanuel
- My First Time...(Voting)
- Why Your Vote Still Matters
- Change And Hope And Blah Blah BLAH
- Soul Searching: October Edition
-
▼
November
(18)
About Me
- Linda
- "I screwed up something a few months ago and I was like, 'You know who wouldn't do that? Tom Hanks. You know who would keep his mouth shut? Tom Hanks.' I should try to be like Tom Hanks." -Tina Fey
I have so many thoughts on this, I can't really articulate.
I started keeping a journal three weeks ago of what exercise I get during the day, and what I eat, and it's the first time I've been eating enough, and working out regularly.
The thing is, calorie counting for me always makes me feel guilty, so instead, I've started planning out meals for the entire day the night before, so that I don't think about it as much while I'm eating. Otherwise I spend the whole meal thinking about it.
I'm inspired by your list. It makes me feel not as alone in all of my own struggles. I never quite got past being like 170 pounds at age 13, and sometimes it's incredibly frustrating, especially when I was anorexic and everyone kept commenting on how good I was starting to look.
Basically, the only thing on my list is "Fuck everyone else." I feel healthy and happy for me now.
That, and as I've said before, just in case I'm recruited by a rogue CIA operative like in Eagle Eye. I need to be in shape!
I read a lot of the health and fitness articles on msn and other sites and have started to wonder about the calorie counting idea myself. Some articles point out that it can be a healthy part of someone's life and that it's the only way to keeping your body at the correct bmi, yadda yadda. For myself, I've noticed anytime I went that controlling route though, the effects were always negative. For example, getting ready for spring break with my roommates in college included not only the gym almost every day for 2 hours, but massive calorie cutting and constant judgment such as "did you see what she ate? did you see how she didn't eat?" blah blah. I reached the point where I was writing down my calorie counts in my books before class started or in the library just to keep myself on track. A. this led to food deprivation and B. once you stop sadistically counting your intake and exercising like a fiend; you inevitably start soften your muscle tone and your body changes again.
We’ve become a society focused on how we look and celebrities and models have taught us that you can’t ever really be too thin as long as people still worship you. I agree 100 percent with everything on your list. It’s taken me the three years since living with the girls at school to reach the point of starting to feel okay to be like, you know what, it’s okay to have the cupcake or burger or whatever. What matters is a balanced diet to maintain a healthy lifestyle and heart. I think anyone looking to lose weight or tone up and maintain that level can learn a lot from how you word the list. Slow, steady and positive wins the race.
diciator
Really, it's about being sensible and trying to recognize what works for you as an individual. For certain personalities (mine), itemization and lots of numbers & analysis really does help, and it doesn't make me obsessive to an unhealthy extent. At the same time, though, I can understand how it could drive a different personality crazy.
I think the second sentence of your point #6 really sums it up.
Also, restricted drinking??
toterge
The ground rules are smart, affirmative, and healthy---well done. It's so easy to let calorie counting drive you crazy, so I think the rules are important---you have to consistently maintain control over the process so that the mathematics of nutrition don't turn into the ruling force of your life.
Just after college I decided to get back down to my fighting weight, which involved running regularly and not so much dieting as paying attention to the food I was consuming. Growing up, I didn't have extensive nutritional literacy---things like portion control, balancing my diet, etc. weren't things I knew how to do. I grew up in a family where we just, well, ate, and we enjoyed it.
After I lost the weight (and then some), I finally decided to start logging my calorie intake and exercise online to see where I was at. That's when I realized that, on many days, I was netting around 700 calories, which is just about what you need to maintain respiration. After that frightening realization, I scaled up my eating and stopped feeling guilty about snacking here and there.
I don't count calories anymore. I still get mad at myself when I get lazy about running, and I feel a little guilty about having that duck ragu pasta at dinner on Friday night. But I will say that, for me, it was necessary to calorie count for a while if only to more clearly understand what all of the food I put into my body over the course of a day meant. Now I'm exercising moderately, indulging appropriately, and happier with my body than I probably ever have been. It's all about finding the balance between knowledge, control, nutrition, and above all, confidence.
We're getting there, I think.